Q&A with The Alchemist’s John Kimmich

Share Article

The Alchemist’s Heady Topper is renowned as one of the best beers in the country, and personally, it’s at the very top of my favorite beers of all time.

John Kimmich, the man behind The Alchemist for the past 10 years, has gone through a lot to get the brewery to the top of the craft beer game.

Heady Topper was just beginning of the craze for his Vermont craft beer. Now people travel and trade from all across the country just to get their hands on beers like Crusher, Focal Banger and Beelzebub (the one I need to get my hands on).

Kimmich obliged a geeking fanboy (myself) by answering a few questions about everything from wild Heady Topper stories to the difficulties of the current craft beer market.

Photo credit Luv Lens Photography

What is the backstory of The Alchemist?

John Kimmich: We started The Alchemist in November of 2003 as a 60-seat brewpub in downtown Waterbury, Vermont. The Alchemist name came from the symbol we use, which is actually the alchemic symbol for fermentation.

We worked our asses off for over 10 years until we were ready to start it. When we found the location, we went for it. The night before we opened, we had about $50 in our bank account, so it was sink or swim at that point for sure.

The flood in 2011 could have set a lot of brewers back, but you seemed determined to right the ship and get back to brewing. What was it like to be at that point and now look at how far the brewery has developed?

It did set us back, it was a total disaster and the Alchemist Pub and Brewery never opened again. We were very fortunate to have started our packaging brewery when we did. We canned our first batches of Heady two days after the flood.

It was the only thing that saved us. We were used to a forward motion, so it all just kind of happened the way it happened.

What’s your background in brewing?

I started homebrewing when I was in college. It hooked me the moment I made my first batch. I had also been working in the brewing industry for about 10 years before we opened the pub.

Photo credit Luv Lens Photography

When did you know that Heady Topper was going to vault into a beer that everyone had to try?

When I gave my three-year-old son a taste of it in the brewery and he said “mmmm..” (Smart kid)

What was your initial reaction when the beer started to earn so much praise from beer lovers nationwide?

I had been making Heady in the pub for 8 years before we ever packaged it for outside consumption. It’s growing reputation was one of the primary reasons we decided to open the second brewery. We continue to be flattered by the response to what we do here at The Alchemist.

What is the wildest thing you have ever heard someone do to get a can/case of one of your beers?

At this point, there are so many. The first was when a guy showed up at opening the day we released a fresh batch. He had just flown in from Florida for the sole purpose of drinking Heady.

Many brewers seem to face a crossroads when faced with growing the size of their brewery maintaining quality. All of your beers have stayed up to par after the expansion, how do you achieve that balance of production and quality?

I am a total control freak, and the quality of our beer is what drives everything. I can’t imagine it any other way. We are not interested in being anything other than a local gem.

Do you have any personal brewing philosophies?

We treat everyone around us with the respect that they deserve. This, combined with our dedicated focus on quality is what drives The Alchemist to new heights.

Photo credit Luv Lens Photography

Does the Alchemist have any plans to operate a pub-style venue in the future?

Not unless Jen [Kimmich’s wife] and I lost our minds. We loved the pub, but that kind of daily grind and liability exposure is not something we want to take on ever again.

What are you looking forward to in the future of craft beer? How do you see it changing in the next 5 to 10 years?

That’s the big question, isn’t it? I see the cream rising to the top, and a lot of the rest going by the wayside.

Many people believe in this “craft beer bubble” and use recent developments like the buyout of Wicked Weed as an example of this bubble starting to stretch. What do you think of this theory?

I am a big believer. I have lived through them in the past. The bubble of the 90s has a lot of similarities to the current landscape. There are a lot of operations being started because they see it as a money-making opportunity. Breweries that aren’t looking 10 years ahead are going to be in for a big surprise. The beer-consuming public has never been more educated on what defines a great brewery.

What’s next for The Alchemist?

The thing that excites us the most is the creation of The Alchemist Foundation. Jen and I are very much involved in creating opportunities in education for those less fortunate.

I wish this was the part of the post where I could say, “You can find The Alchemist beers at …” but unfortunately, you have to know a few guys or take the trip to Vermont for yourself to get your hands on some of this nectar.

James Werner
Author: James Werner

You might also like

Weekend Roundup | Harrisburg Event Listing | Sara Bozich
Featured

Weekend Roundup 11/12

Plan your weekend with my weekly list of things to do around Harrisburg and central PA! In partnership with Knock out your holiday shopping at ...
Events

Kick Off the Holidays at Weaver’s of Wellsville on December 5

Sponsored by Weaver’s of Wellsville If your holiday shopping list includes someone who’d rather get good beef jerky than another candle, I have a stop ...
Featured

GIVEAWAY: Find Your Next Favorite Workout at H2L Studio + Win 10 Classes!

This fall, I’ve been spending more time at H2L Studio in Mechanicsburg – trying different classes, meeting new people, and discovering all that this local ...