Know Your Brewer: Terry Hawbaker at Pizza Boy Brewing Co.

Share Article

Terry Hawbaker said his brewing philosophy centers around balance.

And when you step up to order your beer from the more than 20 Pizza Boy Brewing Co. beers on tap at Al’s of Hampden, you’ll find just that.

Balance.

pizza boy brewing al's of hampden

Whether it’s an IPA with fruit, a stout with chiles, or their killer Brewery Pilsner, it all comes down to balance.

“Balance is what I strive for,” said Hawbaker. “I don’t always achieve it or hit the nail on the head, but I’m also definitely the worst critic of our beer.”

Hawbaker said that he knows the beer can always be better and that’s what keeps him coming back.

Achieving that balance didn’t happen in a few short years. Hawbaker has more than two decades experience in the brewing industry.

He’s opened several breweries, and helped others, like Pizza Boy, expand their footprint in the ever-changing craft beer world.

Early brewing history

Hawbaker’s brewing starts in what is now essentially the toddler years of the craft brewing saga. It was the early 90s, and while moving out of his house in Ohio, he saw the next resident carrying in some brown liquid in two massive glass jugs.

“I asked the guy what he was carrying, and he told me it was beer,” said Hawbaker. “I had no idea you could make beer, and that left an impression in my head.”

He moved to Florida, and while working with Green Peace, he had a friend from Colorado who couldn’t stop talking about all of the microbreweries popping up.

Hawbaker said those two instances really stayed with him. When he turned 21, he went out to a homebrew shop and bought a kit to make a brown ale.

“I thought it was pretty good,” said Hawbaker. “But then I got a little cocky, and the second time around it didn’t turn out so hot.”

Thankfully, for all of us, that didn’t stop him.

“I just couldn’t stop,” said Hawbaker. “At any given time I would have 30-40 cases of beer. I couldn’t sustain it, and I was just dying to get into the industry. I just wanted it so bad.”

Hawbaker got that chance while on a visit back in Ohio while sitting at a local bar.

“I was sitting at the bar, and the owner happened to be sitting beside me talking about how he wanted to open up a brewery,” said Hawbaker. “I said ‘hey, I’m a brewer’ and I pretty much bull shitted my way into the position.”

The place was O’Houlies Pub, which is now Jackie O’s Brew Pub, and Hawbaker said they spent the next two years building and outfitting the space for a brewery.

He spent a year there before heading to Marietta, Ohio to open Marietta Brewing Co. He brewed there for a few years before taking a brewing hiatus and heading to Florida where he worked in an artisanal bakery.

Again, thankfully for us, Hawbaker came back to brewing.

Winning a medal

pizza boy brewing al's of hampden

When his year of bread-making was over, Hawbaker returned to the brewing world at Jones Brewing Co. outside of Pittsburgh, W.T. Hacket in Scranton, and opened up Black Rock Brewing in Wilkes-Barre in the span of a few years.

He then took a job at Bullfrog Brewery in Williamsport for seven years where he helped to grow their footprint and developed their sour program.

At this point in craft beer’s history, a lot of what you did as a brewer was education. Hawbaker said that he initially had difficulty getting people into the sour and Belgian beers.

“My first wild ale bottles ever released probably sat on a shelf for a few months,” said Hawbaker. “I heard people laugh because of the price tag.”

That all changed however after Hawbaker won his Great American Beer Fest gold medal for his Beekeeper Belgian Flemish Red with honey in 2008.

“After I won that medal, it was like the floodgates opened, and we had people coming from everywhere,” said Hawbaker.

That medal almost never happened, however.

“I was shocked when that beer won a medal,” said Hawbaker. “I had my hand over the bung on the barrel ready to tip it into the drain more times than you know. It wasn’t tasting right at all, until one day it did, and we bottled it.”

Hawbaker said from brewery to brewery he always kept learning and that’s one of the things that he loves and still sticks with him.

“Everyday we learn something new, you never stop learning, ” said Hawbaker. “If you stop learning, it’s over.”

Even now, while continuously churning out beer after beer at Pizza Boy since 2013, Hawbaker is still learning.

Continuing education

pizza boy brewing al's of hampden

Hawbaker was caught by the mixed fermentation, Belgian, and sour beer bug early while setting up the first brewpub in Ohio.

Hawbaker said he apprenticed under David Pierce from Bluegrass Brewing Co., and that Pierce was a Belgian beer fanatic.

“He really got me into liking Belgian beers early on,” said Hawbaker. “I was always fascinated by Belgians, and that led me into other styles like lambics.”

His recently discontinued Intangible Ales brand was a testament to that style.

“When it comes to beers, I’m very free-thinking and free-flowing, especially my artistic side with wild ales,” said Hawbaker. “The whole premise behind Intangible Ales was I never gave you any info on the label about what was inside the bottle. Style is subjective, and if you liked it, great, if not, great. That was the whole premise.”

He’s produced a lot of sours in his other brewing endeavors and at Pizza Boy, but his upcoming release of Permasmile presents a new challenge.

Permasmile is a Pizza Boy signature beer. This time around, however, they are doing it on the largest scale they have ever done.

“It’s the biggest blend I’ve ever done,” said Hawbaker. “As many times as I’ve made this beer and other mixed-fermentation and sour ales, but when you do it on this scale, it’s a whole different world.”

Hawbaker said the challenge is blending the beer from 26 different barrels. Some barrels with fruit, some with no fruit, some with two different kinds of fruit, all have to go into two tanks and be blended perfectly.

He said, despite all his education and research he still gets nervous when making these beers.

“I can control every little aspect on my side, and there’s still so much I can’t control,” said Hawbaker. “You just have to give it the optimum conditions and hope it goes well.”

Despite the stress, and the ulcer that he said he was born with from it, Hawbaker still has a love for sours.

“To be able to drink the beer and have something work out that’s so unique that you ultimately had no control over is a very rewarding payoff for all the stress,” said Hawbaker.

A balancing act

Back to balance. It’s not just about the balance of flavors with Hawbaker’s beers at Pizza Boy. It’s the balance of the quality-made beer styles as well.

Hawbaker said a few weeks ago that a team of 20 European brewers from BrauKon gave him one of the best compliments he could ever get as a brewer.

“What I took most out of the meeting with the most pride is that they loved all the beers,” said Hawbaker. “From light lagers to mixed-fermentations, they loved them, and that’s where I can take pride in my brewing.”

The group of European brewers also told him how balanced everything was, and Hawbaker said those were two of the best comments a brewer can get.

“I was pigeon-holed early for the wild and sour beers, but ultimately I love and enjoy making every single style of beer to the best of my ability, and the best I know how to do.”

You can taste Hawbaker’s beer at Pizza Boy Monday-Wednesday, 11 a.m.-10 p.m., Thursday-Saturday 11 a.m.-11 p.m., and Sunday 11 a.m.-9 p.m.

James Werner
Author: James Werner

You might also like

Weekend Roundup | Harrisburg Event Listing | Sara Bozich
Featured

Weekend Roundup 11/5

Plan your weekend with my weekly list of things to do around Harrisburg and central PA! In partnership with Do your holiday shopping at the ...
Events

Downtown Camp Hill’s Candy Cane Walk Returns Nov. 22

One of Downtown Camp Hill’s longest-standing traditions is the annual Candy Cane Walk. And it’s become one of mine, too. I love the opportunity to ...
Featured

Your Guide to Holiday Markets in Central PA for 2026

If your idea of holiday shopping includes browsing local makers and stopping for something good to eat along the way, you have plenty of options. ...